Barbara Petzold Critique Essay

The woman sits in a park, legs crossed, smoking, relaxed. Two men watch her from a window above the park, and they discuss her, looking down on her. "If she were six, you would say she was sulky," one of the men says. "Since her incarceration, her group of friends has been destroyed." She is meeting the two men, and one says, "She won't come in a moment before it's time." It is an eloquent exchange, and even more eloquently filmed, the woman seen in long shot, from above. She knows she is being watched. Her "relaxation," then, is an act of public theatre.


This is the opening scene in Christian Petzold's effective psychological and political thriller "Barbara," and it sets up the tension and atmosphere with precision and a taut elegance. It is East Germany, 1980. Barbara, the woman, played by Petzold's regular muse, Nina Hoss, is a chilly alert blonde. Barbara is a doctor and has been placed in a rural medical clinic as punishment for applying for an exit visa. Given an apartment by the State, Barbara is under constant surveillance by the Stasi. Andre, the doctor who runs the clinic (played by the gentle, hunky Ronald Zehrfeld), is an informer for the Stasi, and yet he does not seem devoted or fanatical in that role. His primary priority is his patients. He would also like to get to The Hague someday, to see Rembrandt's "Anatomy Lesson" in person, although his hope for being allowed such a trip is dim.

Andre recognizes Barbara's gift at her job during her first shift, when she correctly diagnoses a teenage girl (Jasna Fritzi Bauer) with meningitis, the signs of which the rest of the doctors had missed. Barbara, the cool character self-consciously smoking in the park, is an entirely different person at her job. The girl has escaped from Torgau, a Socialist work camp nearby, and Barbara treats her with a mischievous warm camaraderie, and reads to her at night. Barbara's choice of book is significant: The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.

In Mark Twain's classic, Huck and Jim, on the run, take to the Mississippi River in a raft, loosening the fetters that bind them on the mainland, all while plunging deeper and deeper into slave country. Barbara, who has secret rendezvous in a nearby forest with a lover from West Germany, smokes expensive black market cigarettes, and has mysterious meetings with people who surreptitiously hand her packets of money, is a flight risk: you can sense that in her tense posture, and in her wild-looking eyes flicking out the window at the sound of every car horn.


Nina Hoss is a magnificent actress, watchful, tense, and spikily intelligent. When a smile cracks open on her face, the warmth and beauty is heartbreaking, because of the contrast. Hoss' work in all of Petzold's films is good, and while he has used her continuously, she never shows up as quite the same character. The woman in "Yella" is not the same as the one in "Jerichow" or in "Barbara." Nina Hoss can do anything.

In East Germany, in 1980, no one is to be trusted, and Petzold creates that sense of oppression with meticulous sound design (never has a doorbell sounded so frightening), and yawning gaps in between conversations, gaps filled with sound: wind, echoing footsteps in a hallway, trees rustling, the crunch of gravel under bicycle wheels. There is no score. The only music comes from the radio, once, and when Barbara plays her newly-tuned piano alone in her apartment. Barbara's landlady stares at her with cold expressionless eyes, a piano tuner shows up unexpectedly, freaking Barbara out (he must be there to inform on her), and every interpersonal interaction is charged with suspicion. Even the romantic and sexual tension in between Barbara and Andre seems loaded and dangerous.

"Barbara" is extremely suspenseful, without using the common genre trappings. The workings of the clinic are observed in a detailed fashion. Andre has set up a lab where he makes his own serum, a fact that impresses Barbara, accustomed as she is to better big-city hospitals. Petzold's films with Hoss are often about different sub-cultures of work, as well as about the long shadow left by Germany's split: in "Yella," Petzold examines the risky thrill-seeking world of corporate negotiations; in "Jerichow" it's the ins and outs of snack bar ownership, and in "Barbara," the challenges of running an out-of-the-way clinic, short on supplies and staff. There are decisions to be made about the patients (the teenage girl with meningitis, and another teenager, a failed suicide), and these decisions require cooperation and openness, anathema in a police state.

Andre, after examining the boy who attempted suicide, confides to Barbara, "I don't know. Something is wrong. I can feel it." One could say that about the entirety of the world portrayed in "Barbara," a world filled with everyday objects: bathtubs, pianos, bicycles, cigarettes, all of which take on portentous significance when seen in the context of totalitarian culture. Something is wrong in East Germany, and everyone can feel it. Doctors examine a patient and make a guess at a diagnosis.

The reality of Barbara's world, and the world of all East Germans, is one of constant surveillance, omnipresent informers, and a huge gap between private and public behavior. Petzold is a master at creating the kind of tension that can be felt on a subterranean level, a sort of acute uneasiness that can't be easily diagnosed, fixed, or even acknowledged by the characters. This is well-trod ground for Petzold, but never has it been so fully realized, so palpable, as in "Barbara."


Reveal Commentscomments powered by

Christian Petzold is a leading figure of the Berlin School, arguably the first significant collective of German filmmakers since New German Cinema. Originally, the term “Berlin School” referred to filmmakers associated with the Deutsche Film-und Fernsehakademie Berlins (DFFB, the German Film and Television Academy), such as Thomas Arslan, Petzold, and Angela Schanelec. Among the DFFB’s educators are directors Hartmut Bitomsky and Harun Farocki. Farocki frequently collaborates with Petzold, co-authoring screenplays, as he did for Petzold’s new film, Barbara.

Barbara. Directed by Christian Petzold.

At this point, the term refers less to filmmakers associated with the DFFB and more to a style of filmmaking, characterized by long takes, long shots, sparse use of non-diegetic sound, and use of little-known or non-professional actors. Thematically, Petzold’s films tend to convey a sense of the precarity of life in post-reunification Germany (a motif worth exploring there, even if precarity is so much more prevalent in the country’s neighbors to the south). Throughout, Petzold’s oeuvre considers the quest for economic security and how it colors personal relations. Most of Petzold’s films involve characters that have been randomly thrown together and often take place in settings that underscore transience—rest areas, hotels, moving cars—and where financial and emotional interests stand in competition with one another.

Each of Petzold’s 11 features produced to date, including five made-for-television films, rests at the intersection of the main characters’ desire to belong or to have a home (or at the very least, not to be on the run) and the socio-political-economic conditions that thwart or stymie this desire—Heimat-building, or the creation of a home, as Petzold called it repeatedly in interviews he gave on the release of Jerichow (2008). Barbara, too, dwells on these questions of Heimat-building, but marks Petzold’s first foray into pre-1989 divided Germany.

Set in 1980 in East Germany, Christian Petzold’s Barbara tells the story of Barbara Wolff, a doctor (played by Petzold regular Nina Hoss in her fifth film with the director) who has been transferred from the renowned Charité Hospital in East Berlin to a small town hospital as punishment for applying for an exit visa from East Germany. She handles the demotion with cool reserve, preserving a distance from her new colleagues. When the hospital’s head doctor, André Reiser, offers to give her a ride home and seems to know the route without asking her address, she quickly suspects that he has been enlisted as an informant by the East German Ministry of State Security (or Stasi in common parlance) to report on her movements and actions.

Stasi officer Klaus Schütz orders frequent searches of her house and body. Undaunted, Barbara continues to plan her escape from East Germany via the Baltic Sea to join her lover Jörg in West Germany. As the day for her planned escape approaches, the film’s pace quickens, and emergencies demand her attention and force her to decide whether to stay or go.

Filmed in the fall by frequent Petzold collaborator Hans Fromm (Yella [2007], Jerichow, Beats Being Dead [2011]), the film features a palette of lush dark greens, navy blues, muted yellows, cranberry reds, and deep autumnal oranges reminiscent of pumpkins, deliberately avoiding the gray tones often associated with recent films about East Germany. It is a stylistic decision common to recent German films about East Germany: in commentary accompanying their respective DVDs, director Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck stated he sought to avoid grey in his Oscar winner The Lives of Others (2006), and director Volker Schlöndorff said of his The Legend of Rita (2000), “I didn’t want again this cold war lighting where everything is grey.” Barbara is set not only in the countryside but mostly in nature, which is frequently a site of escape: Barbara meets her lover Jörg in the forest for a tryst; the Baltic Sea’s arctic and choppy waves form the proposed route of escape; and throughout the film, Barbara bicycles through the landscape. Other photographic choices, frequent medium-to-long shots, level framing, and long takes combine to create a slow-moving film, with an emotional reserve, but palpable feelings simmering beneath the surface.

Barbara screens at the New York Film Festival and will be released theatrically in December.

Recommended further reading:
Marco Abel, “IntensifyingLife: TheCinemaoftheBerlinSchool,” Cineaste 33.3 (2008).
Jaimey Fisher, The Cinema of Christian Petzold: A Ghostly Archeology (Urbana: University of Illinois, forthcoming 2013).


Christina Gerhardt

CHRISTINA GERHARDT is Assistant Professor of German, teaching 20th century German literature and film at the University of Hawaii. Her writing on film has been published in Film Quarterly, In These Times, and The Sixties.



BARBARA HAMMER with Alexandra Juhasz

DEC 17-JAN 18 | Film

Over tea and croissants at her Westbeth Studio, filmmaker and artist Barbara Hammer met feminist film scholar and filmmaker Dr. Alexandra Juhasz for a lively back and forth about Hammer’s New York city-wide retrospective.

An Excerpt from Slow Writing: Thom Andersen on Cinema
With an introduction by Mark Webber

OCT 2017 | Film

Slow Writing: Thom Andersen on Cinema is the first collection of writings by a filmmaker who is known and much respected for his celebrated documentary essays including Red Hollywood (1996, made with Noël Burch), Los Angeles Plays Itself (2003), and The Thoughts That Once We Had (2015).


with Barbara MacAdam

NOV 2017 | Art

On the occasion of David Row’s recent show, Zen Road Signs, at Locks Gallery in Philadelphia, Rail contributor Barbara MacAdam met with the artist in his longtime SoHo loft filled with examples of his art from various periods.

Stop Motion: On Evan Calder Williams's Shard Cinema

by Phil Coldiron

SEPT 2017 | Film

As someone who, owing to both finances and priorities, has seen only a small fraction of the dozens of recent blockbusters that Evan Calder Williams calls on in his new book Shard Cinema, I nonetheless instantly recognized the sort of image he describes in its opening pages as the point of departure for the wide-ranging inquiry that follows: “the slow-motion shatter, drift, spray, and spread through the air of broken glass, ice, cement, plastic, wood, and metal, of crystalline drops of water and glowing sparks and specks of dust and snow and sand, all given ample screen time to go nowhere in particular


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *